Why South Africa's youth unemployment is, at root, a question of agency

Holly Munks' piece in Daily Maverick is a welcome, practical contribution. Fairer screening, language requirements that fit the job, data-light platforms and transport support are all worth doing, and she is candid that hiring reform alone will not solve the crisis. That candour invites us to ask what else is needed.

Here is my answer: the hiring fixes strengthen one half of what young people need, and the other half has barely entered the conversation.

Necessary is not sufficient

Think of a shop on a busy street. Widen the doorway, add a ramp, print a clearer sign. All good. But none of it helps the person on the pavement who doesn't believe the shop is for them, or who has no reason to want what is inside. Removing barriers makes walking through possible. It does not make anyone walk.

Growth is not development

The article rightly names economic growth as central. Employment depends on positive GDP growth. But growth is a bigger pot of porridge. Development is whether the child can lift the spoon and wants to eat. Amartya Sen put it this way in Development as Freedom (1999): growth is a means, and development is the expansion of the real freedoms people have to live lives they value.

Agency has two legs

Agency is the capacity to act intentionally on your own life, and it stands on two legs: ability and desire.

Ability is the skill, access and opportunity to act. Most of the article's proposals live here, in the external, access side of ability, and they deserve the attention they get.

Desire is simpler than it sounds. It is self-motivation: the inner drive to do, and to become, with purpose. Deci and Ryan's Intrinsic Motivation and Self-Determination in Human Behavior (1985) showed that motivation sustained from within outlasts motivation pushed from outside. William Damon, in The Path to Purpose (2008), described purpose as a lasting intention to achieve something meaningful to the self and beyond it.

Desire is not a trait that some young people happen to lack. Arjun Appadurai, in The Capacity to Aspire (2004), argued that aspiration is a capacity, unevenly distributed because it grows with experience. Albert Bandura's Social Foundations of Thought and Action (1986) adds the mechanism: people act when they believe their actions can matter. Belief is built, step by step, like a muscle.

A car with a full tank and no destination goes nowhere. A destination with no car goes nowhere either. Young people need both.

What a subsidy cannot buy

A transport subsidy gets a young person to the interview. It cannot carry them through the first hard Monday, the first unfair remark, or the third month when the novelty has gone. Staying takes an inner reason. One of the article's own voices makes the point nicely: "Hope is not the same thing as being satisfied with a bad situation." Hope, unlike a bus fare, has to be grown.

The arithmetic

Stats SA puts unemployment among 15- to 24-year-olds at 63.6%. A figure like that does not move by tuning the sieve alone. It moves by changing what goes into the sieve: young people who know themselves, can direct themselves, can express themselves and expect to succeed, long before they ever hold a CV.

Nobody runs a marathon they don't want to finish. Rudder4Life starts in Grade 8, while wanting is still being formed.

So keep making hiring fairer. And keep asking the question beneath it: how do we raise a generation that can, and will, walk through the door?

#YouthUnemployment #Agency #SouthAfrica #WholeChildEducation #Rudder4Life #SEL